Study Shows Well-Defined Solutions Curb Creativity


A study in LEGOs looked at whether more or less instruction makes us more creative.
Image: simone mescolini /

A recent study using LEGOs implies that for adults, following careful directions to solve a well-defined problem can reduce creativity when performing subsequent tasks.

Groups were given LEGO sets and told to either build a specific thing, or to build “something” and, after that, were assigned another task, either ill or well-defined. The groups that tackled the well-defined tasks had a harder time with subsequent, ill-defined tasks, and tended to prefer well-defined task thereafter.

At first glance, the study seems to imply that, while LEGOs are good for teaching kids creative thinking, the building toy is harmful for adults. It is unlikely that this problem is solely one of LEGO, but of how adults think, especially in the workplace. As children, even when we aren’t expressly told be creative, we often “think outside the box” to solve problems because we haven’t learned rote methods to do so. As adults, however, we have had years of learning to figure out how we’re “supposed” to do something–that’s part of the goal of education, in fact.

In a work environment, adults are encouraged to follow specific guidelines in most cases, and they are even punished for not following them, which makes being creative in that environment difficult. This is essentially why progress and invention are so difficult; we develop a system that “works” and stick with it. In less rigid environments, wherein employees are given the freedom to be creative, they are more likely to do so and less likely to rely on rote method.

What the study is really saying is that we can’t have it both ways. Employers, teachers, and parents can’t demand creativity while expecting people to perform exact sequences. Creativity and ingenuity are common buzzwords in a lot of industries, but just throwing those words around doesn’t mean they’ll actually make an appearance. Creativity isn’t like Beetlejuice; you can’t just say it three times and expect it to show up. You have to let it grow naturally.


2 thoughts on “Study Shows Well-Defined Solutions Curb Creativity

  1. Ashley says:

    I believe children start by learning creatively since they have no prior information to base their learning on. They later ‘graduate’ to logical thinking, which is needed for routine learning. Both modes of thinking are important (as are lateral, critical, thinking).

    My ‘Problem Solving’ book series teaches independent thinking, problem solving, and decision making skills. The series starts with logical thinking, since it is the easiest to master.

    Your opinion or even a two minute gut feel on my book’s contents would be appreciated.
    The first four books use fun activities of puzzles and games as teaching aids.
    The contents have already been used to train fresh graduates who are new to the workplace.

    Link to my free ebook:

    Please feel free to pass on this link to students and anyone who may be interested.

    Have a nice day.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s